Readers' Favorite

November 10, 2015

Review: Dear Stephanie by Mandi Castle

by Donna Huber

cover Dear Stephanie

Dear Diary - no too cliche.
Dear Journal - no too formal.
Dear mystery person who will never read this - no, no.
Dear Stephanie ... hmmm. Dear Stephanie, I had a shit day. Dear Stephanie, I just had the most amazing sex. Dear Stephanie, I want to drown in my bathtub. Okay, Dear Stephanie it is. Here goes nothing.

The Review

I wasn't really sure what to expect when I started reading Dear Stephanie by Mandi Castle. The story opens with a prologue featuring a suicide attempt. Then we get to know the main character, Paige Preston, in the first chapter. And I didn't like her.

Seriously she is a stuck-up, rich girl. A real *itch. And I really didn't think I was going to be able to get through this book listening to her whine about her fancy clothes and expensive partying. But then we get a glimpse beneath the plastic facade to the very troubled woman. And I was hooked.

Dear Stephanie was a very emotional story. The story telling method of diary entries was perfect. Even though the partying and other activities may not be something everyone can afford (Paige is seriously rich. She doesn't work but has the best of everything), the emotions and thoughts Paige has is something a lot of people can relate to.

The story wasn't emotional just because it featured a seriously depressed suicidal person, but because it is a "don't judge a book by its cover" kind of story. It would be so easy to look at Paige and ask yourself "what does she have to be depressed about?" But we get a look behind the facade and she the hurt little girl who was all but abandoned by her parents. It reminds us that we don't know what anyone else is going through.

I loved the secondary characters of Blake and Dr. Morea (aka D-Love). I was so happy for Paige that she finally had a psychiatrist that actually wanted to help her and not just take her money and hand out "fun" meds. Then there is B-Large (Paige likes nicknames), her hot neighbor who accepts Paige just as she is.

From the ending I wonder if there are plans to return to the world of Paige Preston. While many things are wrapped up, there is a bit of a what now feeling with the way it ends. I want to be sure Paige gets a happily ever after. There was a good deal of grief in Dear Stephanie and I want to know that there is happiness and good things for Paige.

Overall, Dear Stephanie by Mandi Castle was a great read. The characters and the plot are realistic and heart wrenching. While there are some happy times, this is not a fluffy read by any means.

Buy Dear Stephanie at Amazon

Book info:
available formats: ebook and print (290 pages)
published: May 2015 by Castle Press
ISBN13: 978-0996317504
genres: literary fiction, pychological
source: author
read: October/November 2015

Girl Who Reads is an Amazon advertising affiliate; a small commission is earned when purchases are made at Amazon using any Amazon links on this site. Thank you for supporting Girl Who Reads.


  1. I like the opening, but I'm on fence about whether I'd keep reading.

  2. Okay, now I am hooked. I do love books that dig beneath the facades and show us what is inside. Thanks for sharing...and here's mine: “AFTER I DO”

  3. Not sure it's for me though it does seem well written. Hope you enjoy it.

  4. I am so glad you reviewed this one. I hadn't heard of it before, but it sounds interesting. I like characters who are at first hard to like. And I agree, naming your journal or diary is a great way to go. It's like talking to an old friend.

  5. That is a great beginning paragraph. It gave me a good feel for the narrator. You made me interested in this book.

  6. I am curious - thanks for featuring this one which I wasn't familiar with.

  7. I would have to be in the right mood for this book.

  8. Very good opener.

    My First Chapter post is here if you're interested: